The Upturned Glass: Part 3 of Film Series Salon
Shades of Gray: Framing the Clinician-Patient Relationship in Film Noir
A Salon (Study Group) Facilitated by
Michael Uebel, PhD, LCSW
February 5, 2017 6:30– 9:00 p.m.
Location: Health Learning Building Auditorium, Dell Medical School
1.0 CE/CME/CEU/Professional Development Credits in the topic of ETHICS
Division 39 is approved by the American Psychological Association to sponsor continuing education for psychologists. Division 39 maintains responsibility for this program and its content.
The Salon: This series of 5 films noirs by American, British, and Japanese directors will chart the post-war attitudes toward psychiatrists and doctors, with an attention to the shifting boundaries between patients and their treating clinicians. We will examine three general classes of relationship—the nurturing, the failed, and the malevolent—with the idea that any purity with respect to classification is doomed to contamination; in other words, our own attempts to establish boundaries—classificatory, moral, ethical, and methodological—collapse in the face of border-crossings and interpenetrations. Such a situation throws into question the very notion of what constitutes an ethical clinician-patient relationship, and these five films will offer us ample opportunity to plumb power relations within the treatment scenario. How, for example, is the acumen of the psychoanalyst or the healing power of the physician employed when patients are seen as victims or perpetrators of crime, as potential dupes for the crimes of the doctors, or as representatives of the dark side of humanity? For films noirs may be the best crucibles for examining the limits of human relatedness.
- The Upturned Glass (1948): Brain surgeon (James Mason) offers, in a lecture on criminal pathology, a case study that turns out to be a kind of confession in this grim and compelling post-war noir that echoes the Dostoyevsky of Crime and Punishment, and treats the borders of sanity/insanity and power over life/death. Discussant: John Bedolla, MD